I use Dropbox, OneDrive, Google Drive, and Amazon Web Service’s Simple Storage Service (S3) for online or “cloud” storage and backup. Each has their pros and cons, and each has their role in my setup.
I was reviewing my costs recently. I noted that I have over a terabyte of photographs safely backed up to S3, and concluded that S3 is both inconvenient (it isn’t really “simple” to access) and possibly my most expensive option.
Thanks to a recent change, I’ve settled on Dropbox as my most effective online storage solution.
Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!
- Dropbox works on all the platforms I use: Windows, Mac, Linux, and Android.
- Dropbox synchronization is robust and efficient.
- Dropbox includes file history, allowing me to recover accidentally deleted or corrupted files for up to 120 days (30 days in standard plans).
- Dropbox includes selective sync, meaning I don’t have to store all my Dropbox content on every one of my machines.
- Dropbox, while not the cheapest alternative, is the most cost effective for me.
What I started with
Most of my backups, and specifically my terabyte of photographs and videos, were on Amazon’s S3 online storage. It’s handy in that you only pay for what you use, and it’s exceptionally reliable. I continue to store several websites and support files, such as my podcast and self-hosted video files, there. But S3 isn’t really designed for the “average” computer user to use directly, as I do.
As a Microsoft Office 365 user, I have access to at least a terabyte of Microsoft’s OneDrive storage; five, if I spread it across multiple accounts. Until now, I’ve used this extensively, particularly since OneDrive is so tightly embedded into Windows 10. I had been storing all my (encrypted1) records, music, and other files of convenience for online and off-site backup. With the OneDrive app on my phone, I could access any of the files2, no matter where I was.
I recently added Google Drive to my business’s online storage. I did this shortly after discovering that the server hosting my websites could back itself up directly to Google Drive, which was significantly less expensive than using the storage provided by my hosting provider. In addition, all my websites that had been backing up to Amazon S33 could back up to Google Drive as well. I also use Google Drive to share certain files — mostly Google Docs — with my staff and others.
I’ve had Dropbox seemingly forever. Until now, it’s been a free account, starting at 2 gigabytes of storage, augmented by their referral plan up to a capacity of 22GB. Unfortunately, 22GB is not 1TB, and that’s what I need, if not more.
After analyzing the situation and the alternatives, I settled on Dropbox. Today, all my photos, records, music, and everyday files are stored in my Dropbox account, with portions encrypted using Boxcryptor. (My server backups remain in my business’s Google Drive.)
Here’s why I made that decision.
1. Dropbox is everywhere I want to be.
I’m a multi-platform guy. I regularly use Windows, Mac, Linux, and Android, sometimes all at the same time. Dropbox is the only service supported on all those platforms. (It’s on iOS as well, but I am not, yet.)
One of my ongoing frustrations with relying heavily on OneDrive is that while there’s a reliable client for Windows, Mac, and Android, there is no formal support for Linux. The Ask Leo! web server runs Linux, and one of my older desktop machines runs Linux Mint and acts as a backup repository. While there are third-party solutions to sync Linux to OneDrive, I was never able to get them to run reliably.
Amazon S3 worked just about everywhere except my phone. Even then, it was primarily through command line programs or via integration into third-party file transfer (ftp) utilities. There’s no real automatic synchronization of files without those third-party tools, and my experience was that it was frustratingly slow to use them.
Dropbox is installed and working on all the platforms I use.
2. Dropbox synchronization works
Synchronization is a feature in Dropbox, Google Drive, and One Drive. When a file is changed, added, or deleted in one place, that change is automatically made across all installations of the tool for that account. As I copy photos to a synchronized folder on my laptop, those files are automatically replicated to the cloud and to the other machines on which I have the same cloud storage tool installed.
For me, Dropbox has proven to be the most reliable. If two of my machines running Dropbox are on the same local network — say two machines in my home — they transfer directly, without the slowdown or data usage of sending the data up and down my internet connection. Internet connections come and go, especially while traveling, and Dropbox appears to be very resilient. It transfers when it can, pauses when it can’t, and transparently resumes when the internet connection is available once again.
I’m writing this while traveling, with a somewhat unstable internet connection.4 I’m relying on Dropbox to back up the photos I take on my trip, and it’s just quietly doing its job in the background without any fuss required.
3. Dropbox includes 120 days of file history
One of the major concerns about synchronized cloud storage is that if you corrupt or delete a file, that “change” will be automatically replicated across your storage, corrupting or deleting all copies of the file. While that sounds inconvenient, it becomes a much more serious concern if it’s ransomware encrypting all the files in your cloud storage folder.
Dropbox Professional includes 120 days of file history. (Basic/Free and Plus plans include 30 days.) This makes it possible to recover files as they were before the corruption took place.
OneDrive also includes file history from three to 30 days, depending on whether or not its Recycle Bin is full.
Google Drive, from what I can see, doesn’t include file history.
Amazon S3 does not.
Given the concerns about data loss in light of malware and other threats, file history is a compelling feature.
4. Dropbox Professional includes selective sync
Just because I have over a terabyte in my Dropbox doesn’t mean I need a terabyte of space on every machine on which I have it installed. Heck, I don’t have a terabyte of space on every machine.
Selective Sync is a feature that allows you to specify which folders are and are not downloaded to a particular machine. My terabyte of photographs, for example, is present only on my primary desktop machine and a Linux machine in my basement. Certain sub-folders of photos (typically those I’m actively adding to as I travel) are present on my laptop as well. Other machines on which I have Dropbox installed see that the files are available, but they are not automatically downloaded. (All files and folders are always present in the cloud.)
This lets me easily pick and choose which portions of my cloud storage account I want replicated to any specific machine.
OneDrive includes a similar feature. Google Drive and S3 do not.
5. Dropbox is cost effective for me
Dropbox’s Professional plan includes 2 terabytes for around $200 per year.
Since I continue to use S3 for other things, it’s difficult to put an exact figure on how much I was paying for the storage replaced by Dropbox, but I estimate it as at least $40/month, or close to $500 a year. In addition, since it doesn’t include synchronization tools, it all needs to be managed manually, requiring an additional investment of my time.5
Google Drive (now “Google One”) is less expensive, at $100/year for two terabytes. It doesn’t appear to include file history, and requires third-party tools for Linux support. If you work primarily in the Google eco-system, though, and can compensate for the lack of Linux and history, it’s a pretty good deal.
Microsoft’s OneDrive is complex to compare. A terabyte free with Microsoft Office is pretty compelling … if you have Microsoft Office. At $100 per year, though, it’s almost as cost effective to get Office just for the online storage, as long as a terabyte is enough. Much like Dropbox, it does include file history, though as I mentioned, Linux isn’t supported directly. That the OneDrive client is baked into Windows 10 also makes this a convenient solution if you work primarily in the Microsoft eco-system.
Bottom line: it’s Dropbox for me
Dropbox fills my needs quite nicely. It’s true I could cut costs even more by relying on OneDrive (I’d have to get or somehow manage additional space beyond that first free terabyte) or Google Drive. In either case, my ability to automatically and easily replicate to my Linux machines would come to an end.
In just the few months since I’ve made the switch, it’s already proven itself useful. Particularly when I’m on the road, being able to access my saved reading materials, recent photos, and more via my phone has proven handy. That my photographs — which I copy from my camera to my laptop — are automatically backed up to the cloud and to my machines back home as I travel also adds a level of safety and security.
For me, Dropbox seems the right choice.
If you found this article helpful, I'm sure you'll also love Confident Computing! My weekly email newsletter is full of articles that help you solve problems, stay safe, and give you more confidence with technology. Subscribe now and I'll see you there soon,