Only if you like living even more dangerously
That’s a conglomeration of many questions and problem reports I’ve received over the years. The pace picked up when Windows 10 was released.
Windows Update has a reputation for occasionally causing working systems to fail. The good news is it’s almost always a tiny percentage of machines affected. The bad news is that’s no solace if you’re affected.
I absolutely sympathize. I can understand that making you skittish about ever taking an update again.
And yet, you should.
Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!
Windows Update has a reputation for occasionally causing problems to working machines. The reputation is only partly deserved, and avoiding Windows Update completely is a bad idea. The best way to recover will depend on the failure, but restoring to a previous backup is by far the easiest. Continuing to take updates automatically and having a regular automated backup is the best way to protect your machine from failures, be they update, malware, or hardware related.
Unfortunately, as unlikely as they might be, there are many reasons Windows Update might fail; malware, for example.
Contrary to the opinion of those who’ve been burned, each update is tested before it’s released. Microsoft used to do extensive testing itself, and now relies on members of the “Insider Program” for much of each releases testing.
Even with many people participating it’s still impossible to cover every possible configuration. Indeed, most of Windows 10’s update issues in recent years have been related to specific combinations of hardware.
It’s impossible to test for everything, and just as impossible to predict whether something bad will happen to you.
By and large, Windows Update is reliable and robust. Unfortunately if you’re in the minority of people who have experienced an issue, you probably don’t feel that way.
Avoiding Windows updates
I’m not saying it’s foolish to avoid Windows updates after having a bad experience. It’s a natural reaction to a very frustrating and often time-consuming situation.
But I do believe avoiding updates is a bad idea long term.
The problem is keeping your system up to date is critical to keeping it safe from malware . You want the updates regularly and routinely made available via Windows Update.
You simply must keep your system up to date.
Cleaning up and continuing to use Windows Update
If a Windows Update update caused problems on your machine, the easiest way to recover is to restore to a full-system backup taken prior to the update.
If that sounds familiar, it’s the same advice for removing malware: restore to a backup taken prior to the malware’s arrival.
The irony is not lost on me.1
If you don’t have a full-system backup image, things are significantly more difficult.
In the worst case, you may need to back up your data, reinstall Windows from scratch. Then get completely up to date before continuing. This often also clears up whatever problem might have caused the update to fail in the first place.
If that’s not in the cards, you may be faced with researching the specific failure, and seeing if others have ways to resolve or work around the problem.
If the problem is due to an error on Microsoft’s part you might want to delay updates2 by a week or two after you recover. Updates causing widespread failures are themselves quickly updated and fixed.
Begin backing up regularly. Start today. Daily system image backups are best, so you can restore your machine to a pre-problem state, regardless of whether that problem is a bad update, malware, a hardware failure, or something else entirely.
Keep Windows Updates turned on — meaning don’t try and apply the various hacks that claim to turn it off completely and permanently. If your version of Windows supports it, you can delay updates for some amount of time without turning it off completely. Once the delay has passed, back up, and take the updates offered.
I do believe that Microsoft needs to do a better job of making Windows Update more robust and trustworthy. This is especially true now since much of its operation in Windows 10 is not optional. It doesn’t take many failures for its reputation to be further tarnished. The result is that users take ill-advised measures and end up putting themselves at even greater risk in other ways.