Yeah, I hear those heartbreaking stories all the time, and yes, it is indeed one of the reasons that I talk so much about backing up.
Your concerns about backups are common, as is the desire to test.
Let’s review how you can gain some confidence that your backup will be successful when you need it.
Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!
- A full restore is the ultimate test, but is typically impractical to carry out.
- Test the rescue media by booting from it and preparing for a restore, but stopping before it starts.
- Test a backup image by restoring individual files from one.
- Test a backup image by viewing its contents and making sure all expected files are present.
- You can perform a complete test by replacing the hard drive and restoring an image.
A full restore is the ultimate test
The ultimate way to test backups, of course, is exactly what you ended up doing: performing a full restore of an image backup.
A full restore is the most important to have work, since it’s what can save you from almost any problem. Malware infection? Restore to an image created before the infection, and it’s gone. Disk failure? Replace the drive, restore the most recent image, and you’re up and working again.
The problem for testing backups is that a full restore is really, really risky.
By definition, a full restore is a destructive operation. It erases what’s currently on the hard drive and replaces it with the contents of the backup image. If the restore fails part way through, you’re worse off than when you began. You found out your backup didn’t work, but you trashed what was on the hard drive in the process.
The very restore you would want to be able to fix the failure is the restore your test just discovered doesn’t work!
So, here’s my approach to testing backups.
1. Use the rescue media, prepare for a restore, and stop
Create the rescue media — sometimes called an “emergency disc” — from your backup program. This is the CD, DVD, or USB stick you would boot from in order to perform that full restore. Then boot from it.
Getting this to work is important, because booting from something other than your hard drive can be complicated, particularly in newer machines.
Once the software from the rescue media is running, make sure it can see the drive that contains your backup images.
Then follow the steps to do an image restore, stopping at the very last step before the restore would begin. This verifies that your recovery disk works and the backup program can access what’s necessary to perform the restore.
That’s about as far as you can go without actually performing the restore, but it’s tested quite a bit.
2. Extract files
Most backup programs allow you to extract individual files from your full system backup image. Doing so is another way to test backups.
I recommend restoring a single file.
Exactly how to do this varies depending on the backup program you’re running, but the scenario is the same: delete or rename an unimportant file on your hard disk, and go through the steps for your backup program to restore the file from a backup.
You shouldn’t need to boot from the rescue media. This is something you should be able to do by running the backup software and using it to extract individual files from wherever your backups are stored.
If you succeed, great! You now have confidence the files contained in that backup image can be restored in the event of an actual disaster.
If you fail, however, you know you need to revisit how you’re backing up to make sure you’re backing up what you need in the appropriate way.
3. Check the image
There’s one final test to make sure the files you think are in your backup are in fact in your backup.
For example, in my Maximum Reflect book, I outline how to mount a backup image as a virtual hard drive. You can do this with Windows backup as well. You can then examine the contents of the image to make sure it contains what you expect.
Poke around in the backed-up Windows folders to make sure all of Windows is there. Browse through the folders that contain your data to ensure the same. Look around inside that image to ensure it has what you might need should the worst happen.
There is no 100% guarantee that your backup will work when you need it, but these tests can give you confidence that common issues that often get in the way of an effective backup won’t get in the way for you.
4. A complete test, done safely
There’s one more way to test backups. It involves more work and some additional cost, but it’ll prove beyond a doubt that your backups work.
- Buy a new hard drive.
- Replace the hard drive in your machine with the new hard drive.
- Restore an image to the new hard drive.
If this works, you can leave the new hard drive in your machine and keep the old as a spare.
If it fails, you can simply put the old hard drive back in your machine, and move on to diagnose what failed and why.
If you found this article helpful, I'm sure you'll also love Confident Computing! My weekly email newsletter is full of articles that help you solve problems, stay safe, and give you more confidence with technology. Subscribe now and I'll see you there soon,