Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Why are my Windows Live Hotmail Replies and Messages Blank?

When I reply to a message on Hotmail I’m told by the recipient that the
message I sent is blank. I’m certain it wasn’t, and yet when I look in my Sent
Mail, the message is blank there as well. What gives?

This appears to be a relatively recent phenomenon. Some people are seeing it
while others are not. Some people have found workarounds, and yet for others
those work arounds don’t appear to work.

It’s quite frustrating for those who are experiencing the problem.

And the problem, it appears, is with Windows Live Hotmail itself.

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

The symptoms are this: you reply to a message you’ve received in your
Hotmail account, and by that I mean you type in your reply and you hit
Send. Later you hear from the recipient that all they got from
you was a blank message. When you go to check your Sent Messages, sure enough
the message you thought you sent now appears blank.

First, you’re not alone.

Second, it’s not your fault.

Third, as far as I can tell there’s nothing, really, you can do to reliably
work around the problem.

And yes, that makes Hotmail pretty useless until the problem is
resolved.

Browsing the forums at http://helpcommunity.live.com you’ll find several current threads
of discussion on the problem.

“… as far as I can tell there’s nothing, really, you
can do to reliably work around the problem.”

Some notes from those discussions include:

  • Maximizing your browser window apparently helps some (but not all) people
    work around this problem.

  • It may not happen on all computers.(*) Try logging in to your Hotmail
    account using a different computer.

  • Windows Live Hotmail support appears to have acknowledged this as a problem
    that they are working to resolve.

So the best advice I can offer is to either hang tight, and wait for the
Hotmail folks to resolve the issue, or to switch to a different email
service.

(*) One sub-question that comes up in these situations is “if it’s not my
computer, then why does switching computers make a difference?”.

Hotmail is not one computer. In fact, I’m certain that it’s comprised of
hundreds of web servers that all act as the “internet side” of the Hotmail
service.

Here’s my theory: when you connect to Hotmail, you connect to one of those
servers. As more connections from more people are made, the connections are
spread out over those servers, but each person connects to one of those
hundreds of servers.

Somehow that connection is persistent. That means that if you connect to
Hotmail again from the same machine, you’ll likely connect to the same specific
server that you connected to before. If you connect from a different machine,
then you’ll likely connect to a different server.

And not all servers are experiencing the problem.

This is only a theory. I’m not saying this is how Hotmail works,
but it’s a reasonable explanation that I could see being plausible and that
might explain why you might see different behavior connecting from different
machines.

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

9 comments on “Why are my Windows Live Hotmail Replies and Messages Blank?”

  1. when you reply don’t use rich text
    use plain text
    that is will work around this problem so far.

    hope that will help until Windows Live Hotmail support resolve the problem .

    thanks Leo.

    Reply
  2. Whoa!! Another problem (I’m fighting) is the failure of my first log on to MSN (Hotmail Account), But the next attempt succeeds (same password). This occurs every time.
    MSN has known of this problem for some time (they acknowledged) but have not resolved to date. I’m currently paying for ‘premium’ service. If I didn’t have so much E-mail in them, I’d be in Gmail all the way. Does Leo know how to move my history of E-mails in-total, to Gmail? I’ve got the address list transfered. Roger

    Reply
  3. You can transfer emails from a Hotmail account using the Windows Live Mail Desktop program. Use it, set it up to work with your Hotmail account, then setup, for example a GMail account and if you use IMAP you should be able to get it to upload all your hotmail emails to your GMail account.

    Reply
  4. Sometimes it’s not Hotmail’s fault at all, and sometimes this happens with other e-mail providers and other e-mail applications too. Sometimes, this happens because the virus protection installed on the computer is being TOO thorough – so thorough that it replaces the actual message being sent with its own message saying that “This message is certified to be virus-free.” AVG has this effect in some cases, and I’m sure others do too.

    What always works for me is to check the e-mail protection portion of the computer’s overall virus protection. If it’s set to CERTIFY outgoing mail, disable this function. It’s really an unnecessary, overkill feature anyway, and when it causes problems with e-mails, it’s more than just obnoxious. See if this helps.

    Reply
  5. When I reply to an email, only recently has my reply screen been blank. I mean that the original message is no longer included as it was before. I like the convenience of replying to emails which I can still see as I’m responding. How do I get back that feature?

    Reply
  6. I noticed the same problem with my Windows Live Mail (not Hotmail). There is one sender whose email comes up (Unicode-8). That person’s email is the only on (mulitple emails) that my replies are blank. Others work ok.

    Reply
  7. 6/28/10
    Re: Blank replies: I am having the same problem except there is no acknowledgement that there even WAS a reply. People are now thinking I am not responding to their emails. I’m going to switch email providers. It is imperative to have a “reply” feature. This happened ever since I downloaded the new Explorer 8.

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.