Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Should I upgrade from Windows 98/Me?


For a long time, I’ve been having lots of problems with my PC: freezing up,
error messages, slowness, programs won’t close/end, “blue screen of death” (as
a coworker calls it). Sometimes I have to reboot three times in a row.

Recently my Explorer has started to malfunction with the message: “Explorer
has caused an error in MSHTML.DLL.Explorer will now close. If you continue to
experience problems try restarting your computer.”

With Windows ME I can’t get any more updates from Microsoft. Should I
upgrade to XP or Vista, and in doing so will I lose files, folders or

Windows Millennium Edition (aka Windows Me) was released in late 2000.
Windows 98 was released in 1998, with Windows 98se or “second edition”
replacing it in 1999.

Many people consider Windows Me an unplanned “afterthought” … an attempt
to release something after Windows 98 to fill the gap caused by delays in the
release of Windows XP, which would release a year later.

Almost eight years later, should anyone still be running Windows Me or
Windows 98?

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

Windows XP and its successor Windows Vista represent significant
improvements over Windows 98 and Windows Me (herein after referred to together
as “Windows 9x”). Without getting into horribly technical details, Windows 9x
was fundamentally based on the evolution of the older MS-DOS operating system
which was never really intended to do all the things that Windows ended up
doing. Windows XP, on the other hand, is based in Windows NT technology which
was written from scratch as a more secure, more stable and ultimately
full-featured operating system.

As of July 2006 Microsoft has completely dropped all support for Windows 9x.
While somewhat controversial, in my opinion it’s unreasonable to expect any
company to support all of their products forever. You can argue over the timing
perhaps still being too short, or even question Microsoft’s motives, but the
fact is that support was going to be terminated some day.

“I strongly encourage every one still running Windows 9x
to consider upgrading to something else.”

And, again in my opinion, doing this sooner rather than later was a good
move, if only to encourage more people to move to more stable and secure
platforms – be it Windows XP or even the non-Windows alternatives. Windows 9x
is showing its age, and due to its various issues, was more of a liability to
more users than it was worth.

So in case you haven’t gathered by now, with a couple of exceptions, I
strongly encourage every one still running Windows 9x to consider upgrading to
something else. Particularly because newly found bugs and vulnerabilities are
no longer being fixed in those platforms, continuing to use them presents a
real security and stability threat.

Naturally Windows XP would be the most comfortable upgrade for most people,
however if it meets your needs, switching to Linux would probably allow you to
extend the life of your older hardware that might not be powerful enough for
XP’s higher requirements. Alternately, if you are about to upgrade or replace
your hardware as well, it’d be a fine time to understand whether a Mac might be
right for you.

I did say “a couple of exceptions” above, and I want to clarify that. There
may be things that hold you back:

  • Cost. I don’t want to minimize the fact that not everyone can simply afford
    to upgrade. Clearly there is a risk/cost tradeoff here, and if cost is truly a
    serious factor I’d revisit the applicability of free Linux alternatives.

  • Compatibility. I know of at least one business I deal with that’s “stuck”
    with Windows 98 because the application that they’re required to run is only
    available for Windows 98. (Or, rather, the upgrade to a Windows XP version is
    exorbitantly expensive.)

If you must stick with Windows 9x, and you’re experiencing the problems that
you describe, I would:

  1. Perform a full backup of your entire machine.

  2. Reformat and reinstall Windows

  3. Reinstall all your applications.

  4. Update anything that can still be updated.

  5. Make absolutely sure you were behind a hardware firewall such as a

  6. Make sure you find anti-virus and anti-spyware utilities that still support
    Windows 9x and are being updated regularly.

But I’d definitely prioritize upgrading when you can.

When the time does come to upgrade, how your existing files and folders are
handled will depend on how you upgrade. Again, I always suggest a full
backup so that no matter what happens the files are preserved somewhere. If you
upgrade your existing machine, assuming your hardware meets the minimum
requirements for XP or Vista, then your files and settings should be preserved
as best they can be. If you buy a new machine, I’d actually recommend
installing your old hard drive into the new machine as a secondary drive, so
that you can copy off files as you need them.

Do this

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Less frustration and more confidence, solutions, answers, and tips in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

8 comments on “Should I upgrade from Windows 98/Me?”

  1. Just my two cents worth:

    I have never had a new computer in my life, can’t afford one. But I have had a few over the years. All second hand. Bottom line here is that not everyone can rush out and buy a new system (or for that matter upgrade) evertime Microsoft decides to shove a new operating system in your face.

    My first computer with XP was only a P2-266 mhz, with 64mb RAM. I couldn’t put the SP2 updates on because it bogged down my system to much. I also had to turn of the fancy graphics and used programs like ‘XPLite’ ( to trim down some of the Fat.

    I got lucky at a yard sale recently and now I have a P2-400mhz computer with 192mb RAM. From my experience, its not always a matter of ‘Should you…’ but also a matter of ‘If you can..’.

  2. Microsoft were developing an operating system (beta codenamed Neptune) based on the Windows NT 5 platform in 2000 when they realised that XP was going to be ready first and superceed Neptune before they had a chance to release it, so they abandoned Neptune and released ME instead, but it was not because of a delay in XP. XP was always coming, just that Neptune was supposed to preceed it for the Home user versions.

  3. I must be the ONLY person in the World that had no problems running Me! I thought that XP was a disaster. Ironically, I LOVE Vista!!! :)

  4. Leo! Your telling this guy to do a lot of stuff someone who’s still running WINDOWS ME to do! There’s no way he can figure out how to install a second hard drive, much less backing up and reformatting.

  5. Computer hardware prices have fallen considerably in real terms since the days of Windows 9x, so the cost of upgrading both hardware and software may be less than you think. It really isn’t worth trying to keep old, out of date software running once it’s no longer supported, and if the hardware is that old, it’s probably going to start developing faults sooner rather than later. Remember that there are thousands of hours of development work that have gone into new software, and all this can be of benefit to you and your business at a relatively low cost. You are wasting your time and money by trying to work with a system that has passed its ‘sell-by’ date!

  6. how to upgrade windows 98 to windows xp please anyone tell me

    If your machine meets the minimum requirements for XP, then backup your machine, purchase a copy of XP and boot from the XP setup CD.



Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.