Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Should I maintain my external drive the same way I do my internal?

Should I treat my external drive (used for backups) just like I do my
internal drive which is subject to regular maintenance tasks like Disk Cleanup,
Defragging and so on?

As with so many things, “it depends”.

Whether or not, or how, you need to maintain your external drive depends on
exactly how you use it.

Understanding what each of those maintenance tasks really do should help you
decide.

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

Backup

You mention that you’re using your drive for backups, so this part may not
apply to you. But then again, depending on what you mean by “backup”, it
might.

I don’t even have to ask how you use the drive for this one, the test is
simple: if your external drive died and was completely unrecoverable,
would that be a disaster or an inconvenience? Would you lose things that you
cared about?

If it’d be a disaster you know what that means: you should be backing up the
contents of your external drive. Perhaps you’d get another external drive to
backup to, perhaps you’d backup your external drive to your internal and vice
versa (totally valid, as long as the data is in two places on two different
hard drives), but you should be doing something.

“If all you do is run a backup program to your external drive, then the only
thing you need to do in terms of cleanup is keep an eye on disk space.”

Disk Cleanup

To be honest, I don’t even run this on my primary drive, but then I’m also a
little geekier than average and know what to clean up manually and when.

If all you do is run a backup program to your external drive, then the only
thing you need to do in terms of cleanup is keep an eye on disk space. When the
drive starts to get too full, you’ll need to delete something. Exactly what
depends on how long you want to keep your backups, and exactly how depends on
the backup program you’re using. But there’s nothing that the disk clean up
utility would do that would help.

If you use your external drive for other things disk cleanup may
help, but in reality it’s still going to be focused on items that more
traditionally live on your primary or system hard drive. Even if you’re doing
things other than backup with your external drive you should probably still
just keep an eye on the amount of free space on the drive and take appropriate
action if it gets too full.

Defragmenting

First, realize that defragmenting a drive is only a performance
optimization. In other words the only reason to defragment is to increase (or
maintain) the speed of your hard disk. Particularly with an external drive, the
USB or Firewire interface will often be the real limiting factor on speed and
defragmenting the disk will have little to no impact.

In my opinion defragmenting is really also only called for if the drive is
“busy”. By that I mean that lots of files are being created, deleted, written
to, moved around and so on, every day. That’s typically not what
happens on a backup drive. They get written to infrequently (when the backups
happen) and that’s about it.

Fortunately with most defragmenting tools, Windows built-in tools included,
you can tell whether or not defragmenting even stands a chance of being helpful
by running the analysis that the tools offer. I’ll bet that the majority of the
time there’s simply no need.

Physical Maintenance

Since external hard drives are in their own case and have their own
ventilation systems, this one’s easy to overlook: it’s probably a good idea to
vacuum the ventilation holes to suck up any dust or debris that may have
accumulated. This doesn’t have to happen very often, not even as often as your
main system’s box. But since you should be giving your PC a quick vacuum every
so often, that’s a fine time to do the same with your external drive.

Just remember to turn both off when you break out the vacuum.

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

10 comments on “Should I maintain my external drive the same way I do my internal?”

  1. I have found that when I try to only defrag my USB external drive, Windows decides to defrag the main drive too. I select only the external USB drive to defrag, but after a little while, it stops spinning, and yet Windows says that it is still defragging. It’s kind of annoying, because I write to that drive all day every day, and hardly ever write to the main drive, so therefore, have no need to defrag it. Windows!

    Reply
  2. If it ever comes down to data recovery, then defragged files are much more likely to be recovered. Some products like PerfectDisk allow defragging without opimization.

    Reply
  3. I run a small free utility on my system called “IOBit smartdefrag” which runs automatically in the background and keeps my main drive up to speed. As Linux looks after it’s own drives in it’s own way as standard I though it was strange that Windows had nothing similar and the hard drives always degenerated the files and fragmentation.

    I personally would have belived that todays massive hard drives wouldn’t suffer so much clogging of its file system, but then all the tiny files for windows and many programs are on my C Drive after all…!

    (I always double and triple check comments and independent reviews before using freeware

    Check this out –
    http://www.iobit.com/iobitsmartdefrag.html >>

    Reply
  4. Hi,
    I read that laptop external drives don’t won’t well with Vista. Is this true? Secondly, what external drives (desktop or laptop) do you recommend? I am trying to choose between the Western Digital My Book Edition 500GB ($129.99 at Costco or the Seagate Pro Agent 750GB ($199 at Costco). Please help.

    Thanks,
    Danny.

    Reply
  5. —–BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE—–
    Hash: SHA1

    I’ve not heard that. I’d expect ’em to be fine on Vista, XP
    whatever.

    As for brands … that tends to change from year to year. I
    have two Maxtors I’m quite happy with, and two Western
    Digitals. The WDs are the first time I’ve had one fail
    within a short time, though. It was recoverable (using
    SpinRite), and the drive is still in use and appears solid.

    Leo

    —–BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE—–
    Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (MingW32)

    iD8DBQFHqe3gCMEe9B/8oqERAkcfAJsGppvdwy/9LFlvpKX0A0KH90BMQQCfanQW
    aCa3CbkJv2Gv8dZbzxVbW1E=
    =qq1c
    —–END PGP SIGNATURE—–

    Reply
  6. Nice article Leo. I am wondering about the comment “when it gets too full”. Well, how is this determined? Exactly what is too full? And how will one be notified of this status? About 8 years ago, back when recordable CD drives were still around $450 or so and media was expensive, I did not have the means to back up a secondary storage drive that I had filled to around 80% capacity. It started having problems reading data, and crashed with no recovery option, unless I wanted to spend $1500 (a lot of greenbacks in those days). As it is now, I keep my secondary disk(s) at around 50% storage capacity, but this is a layman’s approach. I have not been able to find any info on external or secondary disk storage recommended limits, so I thought I’d ask you you know what they are or what the generally accepted limits are?

    Reply
  7. —–BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE—–
    Hash: SHA1

    Unfortunately what “too full” means depends *entirely* on
    how you use the drive – there’s no single answer. Could be
    OK to be at exactly 100% capacity, could be bad to have if
    only 50% empty.

    How will you know? Something that attempts to use the drive
    will fail because there’s not enough room to do whatever it
    wants to do. Perhaps you can’t backup. Perhaps you can’t
    save a file. Perhaps defrag doesn’t complete like you want
    it to. Perhaps many other things.

    Sorry there’s really no better answer or reecommendation.

    Leo

    —–BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE—–
    Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (MingW32)

    iD8DBQFIc/DdCMEe9B/8oqERAldiAJ0YImS3dPpZANZ7Qqwv44ZviosNXQCeJwTF
    GDLNfxQ93VgzLTb7QvwFoy0=
    =4qqO
    —–END PGP SIGNATURE—–

    Reply
  8. I have a 500g Seagate. Last night i attempted to run a back up [i use Ghost] and it said my drive was full. So when i checked ‘properties’ indeed, it almost was. So i deleted A LOT of the older back-ups, ranging from 37-41gig each, and still, it said there wasn’t enough room.

    Again, i checked the properties, and the available volume had not changed. So, now i tried ‘disk cleanup’. It emptied the recycle bin, i had no idea the ext. drive had one … but now it’s been working on deleting the ‘compressed files’ [again, i didnt know they were there] but it’s been HOURS and not much change. [the progress bar on the clean up window is only at 1 bar after more than 3 hrs.]

    Is this normal?

    I’ve also attempted a ‘defrag’ but again, windows said there is not enough room to do so. [i’m running XP home]

    It does seem some utilities do not work the same on an external drive.

    Thanks,

    Terese

    Reply
  9. I regularly defragment my external Western Digital hard disk as I do daily synchronization and the files are constantly being moved and deleted as stated above from Leo.

    I have a found a free open source application that defrags external hard disks with ease. Doing a defrag simultaneously as I am typing this actually.

    Works fine in Windows XP and should work on anything, it’s a very robust application.

    Can download from over here:

    http://www.anonsolutions.com/Free-Downloads/

    Then click on dfsetup115.zip

    Just inzip and enjoy 😉

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.