Is dial-up safer?

Slightly.

But in reality, the risk’s not really that high to begin with, and using dial-up adds less anonymity than you might think.

I first want to review the difference that DHCP makes. DHCP (Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol, if you’re curious) is how most internet-connected devices get an IP address, which is used to route data to or through that device. For example, when you visit a website, that site’s server sends the data containing the web page to you at your IP address. Dynamic IP addresses are assigned on-request and can change. When you use dial-up your IP address is almost always different each time you connect. If you’re on broadband your IP address can still change, but it tends to remain the same for much longer periods of time – typically days or weeks.

By having a different IP address each time you connect, it seems likely that it would be more difficult to identify specifically who you are from one time to the next.

Well, for average users even with a static (unchanging) IP address it’s not easy to begin with. I’ve discussed many times that it’s nearly impossible for average computer users to determine who, specifically, is at a specific IP address.

So be it static or dynamic, broadband or something else, using only your IP address you’re already pretty darned anonymous.

Now that being said, law enforcement can of course contact your ISP and probably with a court order determine exactly from where that IP address connects. So in that sense, no, you’re not absolutely anonymous with a static or longer-lasting dynamic IP address.

But the same’s probably true of your dialup connection as well. It’s quite possible that the ISP would also have logs that would allow them to know which of their users connected when, on what phone line, and what IP address they were assigned for the duration of their connection.

In other words, you’re just as anonymous, or not, using dialup as you are on broadband.

The one exception is where it’s not your identity that someone is looking for, but perhaps your activity. For example if your IP address gets banned on a message board, then using dialup you could just disconnect, reconnect, and presumably get a new IP address that wasn’t banned. Repeat that often enough and the board administrator will most likely block all the IP addresses in your ISP’s range of possible IP addresses – blocking any future IP address you might get, as well as all the other dialup customers of your ISP.

All things considered, I’ll just take my static IP address and fast broadband connection over dial-up any day.