In Windows Mail, I received an email from a known vendor (not spam) with all the pictures withheld. At the top (below the header) there was a message which read:
“Some pictures have been blocked to help prevent the sender from identifying your computer. Click here to download pictures.”
My question is: How can a sender identify my computer by me receiving pictures? And of course, how great is the risk?
“Identifying your computer” in that informational message is somewhat vague, as it’s not exactly what can happen. But the concept is still important.
And in fact, if you’ve ever seen ads or services that claim “we can tell you if your email has been read” – images are how they do it, and it’s also why they can never be 100% reliable.
Email image types
There are two types of images in email: attached and remote.
Attached images are exactly that: they’re attached to and sent with the email message itself. When the message is displayed, your email program need look no further than your own computer for the images, and typically will display them right away. Attached images can be displayed in the body of your email, or they can appear as actual attachments. In either case, however, they were sent with the email itself.
Remote images, not surprisingly, are also exactly that: remote. The email message actually includes a link (or reference) to the image, rather than the image itself. The intent is that when the email is displayed, the email program will use the link to fetch the image from wherever it resides on the internet, and display it.
In either case, the email can look exactly the same.
Each of the two techniques has pros and cons. Attached images make your email larger and slower to download and deliver, but probably faster to display. Remote images create smaller emails, but assume that the images can be fetched at the time the email is displayed, which is not always a valid assumption.
Most email programs today will block remote images by default, unless you indicate that a particular sender is “safe” by adding it to an address book or some kind of safe list. This is typically what’s happened when an email arrives and all you see are red dots or empty holes where the images should be.
Now that we know what remote images are, let’s look at how they can be used and abused.
How remote images work
Let’s say I send an email to a large number of people. In that email – formatted in HTML – I include a link to an image on my server, like this:
In HTML, it would be encoded like this:
<img src="https://img.askleomedia.com/puppy200.jpg" alt="Corgi Puppy!" />
And if displayed, would look like this.
That image is hosted on my web server1, and because of that, each time the image is displayed by an email program, or by someone reading this article, the retrieval of that image is logged.
That’s how I can track how many people displayed the image. Note that this is not the same as the number of people that opened the email – since images are blocked by default, there’s no reliable way to do that.
So far, though, we haven’t identified anything about you specifically. That doesn’t take much of a leap, though.
Tracking you via remote images
Let’s assume once again that I’m sending a large mailing to a number of people. In that email, I include the same image, but this time I add a little something to the HTML:
<img src="https://firstname.lastname@example.org" alt="Corgi Puppy!" />
Here the mailing list software automatically includes the email address the message is being sent to as part of the link to the image.
There are many, many techniques for doing and hiding this, but I’ve chosen something easy and obvious for this example. Each email contains a link to the image, “personalized” with the email address of the recipient.
When the email program fetches the image, it asks for:
Since this is an image, everything including and after the question mark is ignored by the web server, which just returns the image.
But the full reference, including the “email=” part, is logged in the web server’s access logs.
And now I can tell not only that the message was opened and the image displayed, but exactly who opened it.
Unless, of course, images are blocked in your email program.
Abusing remote images
So how can this information be used and abused?
Well, with spammers it’s easy: if they see that a particular email address has opened a message and displayed an image, the spammers now know that they have a valid email address that someone actually looks at. You can expect more spam.
With legitimate businesses it’s a little less clear, and in my opinion, a lot less concerning. They do track “open rates” to see how effective their messages are. They know that not everyone displays images, but they can observe trends in the portion that do.
Businesses can also track individual open rates if they want to, using the techniques above. Exactly how they might use this information varies, depending on the business. As one example, I use it to see how many people open The Ask Leo! Newsletter. Among other things, this helps me understand just how useful the newsletter is to my readers.
My configuration is simple: I leave images blocked by default, but add almost all the business senders to my whitelist, so I can see their messages in all their glory.