Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Can my ISP turn off my modem if I use bittorrent?

Is it possible for an ISP to physically shut down your dsl modem
remotely to stop you from using bittorrent?

Specifically, I use bittorrent to download files and sometimes (not
all the time) a few seconds after I start a download and it ramps up to
top speed, my modem’s status light stops blinking, my dsl link light
goes out and I have to turn my modem off then back on in order to
reconnect to the internet. I never have troubles with my internet
connection while gaming (I play World of Warcraft) or surfing websites.
Ever. This happens only when I download using bittorrent, though I
haven’t tried using other download programs or protocols.

It depends on the modem, but I can certainly see it as being
possible.

But I don’t see it as being likely. ISPs have other ways of dealing
with bittorrent, if they’re going to care about it.

I think something else is more likely.

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

The interesting thing about bittorrent is that when allowed to run
“full speed” it can pretty much saturate your internet connection. By
that I mean that you can be both uploading and downloading at your
connection’s maximum capacity.

That’s a fairly unique and uncommon situation. Everything else
you’ve described, even World of Warcraft, doesn’t put anywhere near
that kind of load on an internet connection.

“… it certainly is possible that your ISP
might have the ability to remotely shut down your modem. … The
question is would they?”

What I’d be more suspicious of is a line or modem problem. By trying
to push the maximum amount of data through your connection you might be
pushing the modem into failure. It might have a problem that normally
it can recover from so you’d never notice, but at maximum capacity it
can’t. Similarly, you might have a line noise problem – the telephone
lines that carry your DSL connection often have small amounts of
electrical noise. Once again, it’s possible that your modem is able to
compensate during “normal” usage, but can’t deal with it at maximum
capacity.

Now, I have to admit it certainly is possible that your ISP might
have the ability to remotely shut down your modem. They often do have
the ability to remotely administer it, so shutting down doesn’t seem
like that far-fetched an ability. The question is would they?

In my opinion they have other, less drastic ways of dealing with
bittorrent.

The problem with bittorrent, from an ISPs point of view, is the same
as what I mentioned above: you’re maximizing your use of your internet
connection. That places an additional burden on the ISPs
infrastructure, as they typically aren’t built out with enough capacity
to actually handle the majority of their users using maximum capacity.
As a result, their ability to serve all their customers can be
adversely affected by those few who do run bittorrent.

Lest you think they should just build out more capacity, consider
the cost – which they would then have to pass on to their customers,
meaning you. It’s a common, and accepted design approach. Even the
telephone company has this same restriction; if everyone
picked up their phone at the exact same time the telephone
infrastructure could not handle the load. We occasionally see this at
times of natural disasters. The good news it that the maximum load
scenario is uncommon and things work just fine the rest of the
time.

The same is true of the internet infrastructure. If everyone maxed
out their connection then it would likely work for no one.

All that being said, the ISPs have other ways of dealing with things
like bittorrent that, while somewhat controversial, avoid the
all-or-nothing approach of turning you off.

  • Throttling: the most common approach is for an ISP
    to identify the specific packets making up your bittorrent connection,
    and slow them down. Much like in most bittorrent clients you can
    instruct the application to use no more than a certain amount of
    bandwidth, ISPs typically have the ability to do the same. The effect
    is that your bittorrent transfers will be slower than they could be,
    but the rest of your internet experience, and that of other customers,
    is largely unaffected.

  • Blocking: an extreme measure is to simply block
    bittorrent traffic completely. Some ISPs terms of service prohibit it,
    and they can do that by identifying bittorrent
    traffic and simply refusing to pass it on. The net effect to you is
    that bittorrent simply doesn’t work.

  • Disruption: this is a very controversial approach
    we’ve heard about in the press in recent months. It’s basically a form
    of throttling, but instead of slowing down your traffic some of the
    many connections used by the bittorrent protocol are simply and
    randomly dropped. The net effect is similar to throttling: your
    bittorrent transfers are slower.

All of these are just as complex as shutting down your modem when
bittorrent traffic is identified, and since they’re less disruptive on
other internet usage I’d expect ISPs to rely on them instead.

The bottom line: check with your ISP. Read the terms of service and
see specifically what is, and is not, allowed. If you find that
bittorrent traffic is disallowed, and especially if that’s backed up
with technology to slow or disrupt it, then your only real option is to
find a different ISP that will allow you to use it.

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

14 comments on “Can my ISP turn off my modem if I use bittorrent?”

  1. Another method I’ve seen, which my ISP has been employing for a couple of years and is a variant of disruption, is forced assigned IP address change.

    Most broadband users are dynamically assigned an IP address by their ISP every time they connect. Usually this address doesn’t change during an online session: most ISPs specify a minimum “time out” period over which the address is “guaranteed” not to change, typically 24 hours.

    If an ISP detects traffic that they don’t like, or just an extended period of high volume, they can force your assigned IP address to change. This will terminate most P2P connections like Skype and force bit torrent clients to re-initialize their peer connections.

    Reply
  2. uTorrent can encrypt your bittorrent traffic, so your ISP won’t recognize them (I don’t know for other clients).

    That can help some, but there are other techniques ISPs can use to analyse your traffic besides looking at the content of your packets. (Port usage analysis and blocking are the next most common.)

    -Leo

    Reply
  3. Make sure you aren’t using the default port in your torrent application. Same goes if you are running any type of server. Most ISP’s don’t like servers and file sharing applications and will block all default ports that are used. A likely port to be blocked is Port 21 (for FTP Servers) and so on.

    Reply
  4. Another thing to note is that you can manually throttle Bittorrent so that it does not consume your full bandwidth. The settings vary from program to program, but if the problem is related to your modem crashing due to high usage, I’d recommend trying to lower Bittorrent’s output first.

    Reply
  5. So from what I have read so far is that my dsl provider can shut down my ip because I’m using a bittorrent program which has happen to me and then I have to wait aleast 2 hrs to get back on is there anything I can do to prevent this

    Switch providers? Contact your provider and see if there’s a service class you could pay for that would allow you to use your connection more heavily? I’m sure that the bittorrent folks have ways to disguise the bittorrent connections as well.

    – Leo
    20-Dec-2008
    Reply
  6. My ISP turn off my internet connection because of bittorent downloading. They informed me a Paramount monitor had contacted them stating I was downloading movies via bittorent. I was informed to remove my torrent downloading program & given a 1st offense warning!

    Reply
  7. My service was shut down. I had an actiontec PK5000 wireless router recently installed. The service was temorarily shut down, and I received a 1st warning phone call from a man who said I was downloading copyrighted media files. I asked him what files, and he said, ones you do not have the copyright to, like movies and music. He was unwilling to give specifics. I spoke to a friend who told me that ISPs ARE allowed to search your physical hardrive up to 3 files deep. He also said I had to undownload all these files. I said, what do you mean, undownload, don’t you mean erase? undownloading is impossible.” He said” you have to undownload these files”
    Anyhow, now I am paranoid and [edited] deep in research on what these people can see on my computer and trying to figure out if I can get away with any torrent use at all… Encryption… tor??? Throttling uploads… not sure what will work. What if one of these media companies is spying on me via a piece of spyware??? Is any of this espionage legal, and if so, why?

    Reply
  8. I had my internet connection shut down for similar reasons my cable company turned my connection off not because of my downloading any information but because someone had taken a movie off from my pc… She did however list off several things I had just downloaded kind of scarry that they track every little thing.

    Reply
  9. my isp left a voice mail saying warner brothers claimed i had violated a copyright and the isp was disabling my modem. i am to call and speak to the customer service and given some kind of id code. i still have internet connection but it is painfully slow. is the limitation specifically in my “modem”? or can i go to walmart and buy the same model and problem solved?

    You need to speak with your ISP.

    Leo
    03-Mar-2010

    Reply
  10. MY ISP Did the Same Thing, I got up in the morning brewed my coffee sat down to watch my morning youtubes and the net was off with a message saying My net had been disable and to contact customer Service, I did and they told me 2 movie files had been reported DL on my IP, I was told to Uninstall Torrent Software then call them back and if file sharing was off they would reconnect me, seems off that they can force you to Uninstall a legal Program or track your downloads talk about invasion of privacy, not to mention I run an Open Wifi, so it could have been any one who DL off my IP..

    You probably gave them the right when you accepted their terms of service. Another lesson: don’t run an open WiFi.

    Leo
    23-Apr-2010

    Reply
  11. That is a load of bull. Nobody, I mean nobody, has remote access to anybody’s computer. First of all in order for them to go to your hard drive they need root access (or admin if on windoze). Second, you need software to even allow remote desktop viewing. Third, and the fail-safe, you need to accept a prompt that says they’re about to rape your computer. They cant do that whether you did something illegal or not, because to begin, that’s violating “cyber crime” laws. All your ISP has control of is your Connection, and that is all. No more. If they do decide to break into your computer, that is cracking by definition. If they did this all the time, ISPs would get sued here and there. Because it is just as illegal. But this wouldn’t happen.. You people are getting calls from Warner Bros., or some other company trying to scare you.

    Reply
  12. Isp’s dont need remote access or physical access to your pc. As an isp is in a way a toll booth on a highway. They can see all the traffic running through from a(source# to b#isp# arriving at c#consumer). No way of cloaking your activities from them, as not all websites encrpt data for delivery.

    You can encrypt all your traffic through your ISP with a VPN. The VPN service, of course, can see your traffic.

    Leo
    07-Aug-2010

    Reply
  13. My ISP locked my modem this morning actually, due to file sharing, they said it was unfare for me to use that much bandwith.

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.