Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Why is Thunderbird saying your newsletter might be a scam?

Thunderbird thinks my
newsletter
is scam.

Well, it does by default, anyway.

It’s actually an interesting feature in Thunderbird, but it can also be
misleading or flat-out wrong.

Case in point: my newsletter is no scam.

In this video from an Ask Leo! webinar ,
I’ll show what Thunderbird is looking for, and what it thinks is a scam.

]]>

View in HD (1280×720)

Transcript

I love your newsletter (thank you) the one thing I find annoying is that my email program, Thunderbird, always adds a warning to your email saying this message may be a scam. When I click on ‘Ignore Warning,’ then I can access all the links to the Ask Leo! Website. If I don’t click on the ‘Ignore Warning’ button, it asks me to confirm my action every time I click on the link, which is annoying. Is there any way you can configure your email so Thunderbird knows they are genuine and not a scam? Or how I can configure Thunderbird to know your emails are legit?

OK. I run Thunderbird and I don’t see this because I’ve configured it not to tell me. What Thunderbird is doing is (let’s see if I can come up with a good example of this, because it’s actually an interesting one for us to talk about). Let’s go to the latest newsletter. So somewhere here I probably have … here’s a good example, this sponsor link. This is the web archive of the most recent newsletter. In the actual emailed version of the newsletter, what I’m about to describe actually applies to every link in the newsletter, but because this is a web archive, the same thing isn’t happening. So, if I hover over the Kindle Fire link here, you can see down in the lower left corner of the browser the actual link that it goes to is go. ask-leo.com/kindlefire; in other words, it says Kindle Fire, but it’s going to something that is labeled Ask Leo!. If there are any links that actually look like http links (I don’t see any here), the same problem can occur. What Thunderbird is doing is it’s taking a look at the links on that page and saying, “Does what this page is going to match what it says it’s going to?” And if it’s not, it calls that a scam. It’s an interesting thing to look at in Thunderbird, but the problem is that while scammers do in fact use this, they also, this technique is also very valuable for other reasons. Obviously, when you click on Kindle Fire, you are not expecting to land on an Ask Leo! page and in fact, you don’t. This happens to be a redirection that takes you to the Amazon page. This kind of redirection is very, very common in email newsletters, on websites, and so forth because what it allows me to do is, it allows me to figure out how many people bothered to click on that link. It tells me in the case of an advertisement how effective that ad is; in the case of all these other items, it tells me which articles most people are interested in; if people are ignoring an article completely, I know that it’s not probably a topic I want to talk more about but if I get a lot of click-throughs on an article then I know that’s something of interest.

So Thunderbird is doing its best to protect you but unfortunately the collateral damage is email newsletters. And yes, I do use my own ‘search’ a lot. Let’s see … so … ‘Why does my email program think that this message might be a scam?‘ I actually wrote an article about this some time ago that describes exactly what is happening. This is the message that you are seeing; that the person who is asking the question is seeing and in this particular case, here is a very firm example of where the link says it’s going to Microsoft.com, but in fact, if you take a look at the destination down in the lower left-hand corner, you’ll see that it’s not going to Microsoft.com at all; it’s like the classic definition of a scam link. In this particular case, it’s benign but the other case is the case where somebody says, “Hey, here’s a link to Paypal,” but it’s not. So that’s what Thunderbird is trying to protect you from.

When I use the newsletter, like I said, all of the links in the newsletter get changed to be these kind of ‘click-counting’ redirections so that I can see what parts of my newsletter are effective and understand what people are truly interested in. Now to go back to Thunderbird, unfortunately, I had hoped that Thunderbird would allow me to turn this off on a ‘per sender’ basis but they do not. It’s an ‘all-or-nothing’ kind of a thing. So, if you go into the Tools, Options, Privacy, the Email Scams tab, you can turn this option off completely so that Thunderbird doesn’t check emails for this kind of scam. As I said, it’s very common; you’ve probably seen it in other legitimate emails as well. I will leave to you as to whether this is something you want to turn on or off. The risk of turning it off of course is that you inadvertently click on a scam link and didn’t realize that it was one because nobody told you. The upside of turning it off of course is that you don’t have to deal with it in legitimate emails; you don’t have to worry about emails from me or from other senders who are using this technique that is obviously being confused with a scam. So, I’ll leave it up to you; it’s a matter of how confident you are in your own ability to identify potentially scam links in email. As you might imagine, I have mine turned off completely. It’s just not, to me, it’s not worth the annoyance of having that thing pop up all of the time.

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

3 comments on “Why is Thunderbird saying your newsletter might be a scam?”

  1. Hey, Leo, could you do us a favor and throw some paragraph breaks into your video transcripts? Have a look at how long those paragraphs are above. They’re incredibly hard to read.

    Thanks!

    Reply
  2. Ironically, my mail server flagged this newsletter (with the newsletter spam topic) as possible spam, even though it has never been bothered by your past newsletters.

    Reply
  3. Quite frankly I am cheesed off with Thnderbirds “possible” scam messages. I receive many scam Emails and not one of them is seen as a possible scam by Thunderbird. On the other hand half of the newsletters I receive and open on a weekly basis are marked as possible scams.

    I don’t let it get to me. I just turn it off. Smile

    Leo
    12-Jun-2012
    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.