Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Is it safe to perform maintenance on a recovery partition?

I have a Compaq notebook with Vista Home Premium 32 bit. HP/Compaq
machines have D:\ recovery partitions, and I’d like to know if I cam
run Clean Disk, Check Disk, and Defrag on D:\.

Vista from HP has by default C:\ and D:\ on a monthly defrag
schedule. My Security program tells me C:\ is 1% fragmented and D:\ is
15% and recommends I defrag D:\. My security program just sees D:\ as a
drive and not a recovery partition I assume. So, I don’t know if I am
allowed to defrag D:\ or perform any basic maintenance on it. I also
don’t understand how D:\ got 15% fragmented to begin with.

Personally I’m amazed at how little information manufacturers give
you sometimes about how they decided to set up your machine. HP and
Compaq aren’t the only ones to create a D:\ partition and use it for
recovery, my Dell laptop came the same way.

I mean, they could at least tell you what’s on it and what it’s
for.

So, what’s safe to do to it?

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

First realize that it’s not just your security program that sees D:\
as “just another drive”, because that’s exactly what it is: just
another logical drive. A portion of your hard disk that’s been
partitioned off to appear as a second drive letter. No more, no
less.

What makes it the recovery partition is what your manufacturer puts
on it, and the tools that know what should be there should you ever
need to perform a recovery.

“So while some things are safe to do, doing
nothing is also very safe.”

So, with that in mind:

  • Defrag: go for it. Like you I’m surprised it came
    fragmented, but there’s nothing at all wrong with defragmenting (or
    “defragging”) it. Given that the drive is never used otherwise, you’ll
    probably only need to do that once.

  • Chkdsk: go for it. It better show no errors,
    though, otherwise I’d be concerned that the contents of the recovery
    partition may be corrupt. That’s good to know now, as opposed to later
    when you actually need it.

  • Clean up: it’s probably safe, but in all
    honesty, I’d avoid it. The problem is that we don’t really know with
    absolute certainty that a cleanup wouldn’t delete something important.
    Almost by definition everything on the recovery partition is there for
    a reason, and even if not, that’s the assumption we need to make. (Mine
    even has a recycle bin with deleted files. My guess is that’s just
    being sloppy, but I’m not going to take the risk; I’m leaving it alone, just in
    case.)

Now, there is another alternative.

Do nothing. Ignore it. Don’t touch it.

The recovery partition is not part of your normal, day-to-day use of
your machine. Defragging it won’t help you in any way. Chkdsk might
tell you of a problem ahead of time, but if the recovery partition’s
never been used the chance of there being a problem are very small. And
cleaning up the drive, besides having a small chance of deleting
something important, also won’t help you, and won’t free up any space
that you’d actually use.

So while some things are safe to do, doing nothing is also very
safe. In fact, perhaps the safest of all.

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

7 comments on “Is it safe to perform maintenance on a recovery partition?”

  1. I submitted the question and was very pleased you selected it for an answer ..HP Support has kept my ticket open and just replied that the “fixed image recovery partition” cannot become fragmented, its size is fixed so no room to become fragmented..also informed that any attempt to defrag will just receive an error message..they would not comment on why or how Security program sees it as 15% fragmented if it cannot become fragmented…also would not comment on why HP installed Vista OS has defrag default set to defrag C:\ and D:\ since D cannot get fragmented and will just generate an error messsage. Which I guess all HP/Compaq owners are receiving even though I have yet to get the error message. If I had Vista OEM OS installed I could understand why C and D on defrag schedule. To Vista OEM C and D are real (not virtual) seperate drives. The HP installed version of Vista OS should know D is an image (a virtual drive) not a real second drive. So, your comment “I’m amazed at how little information manufacturers give you sometimes about how they deceided to set up your machine” is why I have persued this with HP and also with Microsoft. Your clear and concise response to my question is allot more than HP and Microsoft have done. Many thanks and much respect for ask-leo.com

    Reply
  2. This article has me wondering if it’s overkill to backup the backup partition on a regular basis? After reading some of your commentary, I purchased Acronis True Image 10 and have it set up to make an incremental backup of the C: drive every evening to an external USB hard drive. About once I month, I switch to another partition on that external drive and make a new full image, followed by nightly incremental images. Every month, I also make a full image of the backup partition, D: on our laptop. The PC doesn’t show a backup partition, but does show a FAT16 and a FAT32 partition, so I back those up once a amonth, too. I’m not doing incremental backups on them, but am I wasting my time on these additonal partitions?

    Reply
  3. how do i open a Recovery Partition this partition on my HP pc it has seemed to fill up and i cant to see what is in there . i can not defrag because it has onley 14% free space left.. please help
    Barry

    Reply
  4. I have an HP pavillion 521n desktop pre service pack XP Home 55277OEM edition, is there a way to update the recovery partition w/ M$ SP2 and SP3
    so that I dont have to languise with the blasted post install of these Packs??? I am fairly computer literate, have found info for Windows XPe, BartPE, liveCD. I am able to access the hidden partition at will? I severly need help with this conumdrum!!!

    Reply
  5. My HP laptop has Windows XP and a recovery partition.

    I’m wondering what happens when I install Windows 7.

    Does the recovery partition now recognise Windows 7 or does it default back to Windows XP?

    I believe recovery partitions are unaffected by any installs, and thus are left with whatever they had before. In a case like this I believe it renders the recovery partition with XP useless once the machine has been upgraded to a different version of Windows like 7.

    Leo
    08-Aug-2009
    Reply
  6. I just wanted to add a little note about adding Windows 7. On my desktop, my main hard drive has 2 partitions – 1 with XP (F:)and 1 with Windows 7 RC (C:), and I added a 2nd, larger hard drive (drive G:) where I store all of my videos, pictures, flight simulators, etc. I can access drive G from either OS. When installing Windows 7, it MUST be installed last! If you need to re-install XP for whatever reason you’ll most likely need to install Windows 7 again as well. The reason for this is that when your computer boots up, you’re given a choice of ‘starting Windows 7’ or ‘start using an earlier version of Windows’. If Windows 7 is installed before XP, XP doesn’t ‘know’ to give you a choice and will automatically boot into Windows XP. You’ll still be able to access anything stored by Windows 7 on the hard drive, but the OS itself won’t run and you’re stuck in XP (unless you know how to change these settings in the BIOS, but the average user probably doesn’t).

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.