Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Is “Defender” enough, or do I need additional anti-malware tools?

I purchased a new computer, OS Windows 7. It came with Defender installed,
also Norton on trial, but the trial is terminating very soon. I’m thinking of
Security Essentials as a download, but I am concerned that it will conflict with
Defender or AVG or other anti-virus software downloads. Will both work without
conflict? Can you give me advice as to what is the best security for my
computer that will not cause problems? Can Defender stand by itself or do I
need to add another anti-virus program to my computer?

In this excerpt from
Answercast #74
, I look at some confusion around “Defender” and versions of
Microsoft Security Essentials.

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

Multiple anti-virus programs

So this is a case where I believe Microsoft has done us a grave disservice
in the way they’ve named things.

The “Defender” that comes with Windows 7 is, in fact, only an anti-spyware
product. It is an anti-spyware scanner. So yes, absolutely – you do need
something else in addition to that.

That’s not true for Windows 8. For people who are reading or listening to
this and thinking about Windows 8, Windows 8 comes with something called
“Defender.” And guess what? It is both an anti-spyware and an anti-virus
program. It can pretty much stand on its own.

It is effectively “Microsoft Security Essentials” with a different name.

Microsoft Security Essentials

What I typically recommend for people in your situation (with your Windows 7
machine) is to download and install Microsoft Security Essentials.

That will automatically disable Windows Defender. It knows that Defender is
going to be there; it knows that Defender is no longer necessary because
Microsoft Security Essentials contains all of that functionality plus
anti-virus.

It’s a good replacement for Defender, and it will handle it
transparently.

Duplicate malware programs

Now, as for the other anti-malware programs that you’re talking about:
Norton and AVG and so forth?

I typically don’t recommend that people need all of them. I think
one good solution is a great place to be. Microsoft Security Essentials is the
solution that I typically recommend for people – and it’s the solution I use
myself.

Now, if you want to have Norton or AVG or something else on your machine,
typically it’s OK to have them there.

Clashing real-time scans

What’s most important is that you not have any of their real-time scanning
functions enabled.

It’s not the presence of duplicate software that causes the
problem, it’s the attempt of more than one anti-malware product trying to do
real-time scanning at the same time. That’s when they can come into
conflict.

This could do two things:

  1. It can cause false positives (where they’ll both be complaining, or one or
    the other will be complaining about a problem that really isn’t there);

  2. Or worse, they can interfere with each other’s ability to detect malware –
    and malware will go undetected.

So, if you have those tools there, they’re fine. You can have them. They’re
good for on-demand scans. But any of the automatic stuff? I would make serious
attempts to be sure you’ve got them completely disabled.

My most serious attempt is to not even bother having them on the
machine!

Microsoft Security Essentials, or AVG, or Norton? Just one of those
would be a fine solution to getting your machine protected. I happen to
recommend Microsoft Security Essentials.

Then, later, if and when you run into a problem, then you can take a look at
saying, “OK, fine. I’ve got some malware on my machine somehow. Let’s get an
additional program or two to scan the machine to clean it up.”

Those would be “on-demand” scans – without doing the real-time scanning that
we know can cause a problem.

Anti-virus AND anti-spyware

So, ultimately, Microsoft Security Essentials will transparently replace
Defender, which is exactly what you want.

Regardless of whether you use Microsoft Security Essentials or not, I
recommend that you have one good anti-malware package (Microsoft Security
Essentials or AVG or any of a number of others) to keep your machine
protected.

You do not need to load up on multiple anti-malware tools at once. It will
slow down your machine and potentially cause you a lot of false positives or
worse – missed detection.

(Transcript lightly edited for readability.)

Do this:

Subscribe to Confident Computing! More confidence & less frustration -- solutions, answers, & tips -- in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

4 comments on “Is “Defender” enough, or do I need additional anti-malware tools?”

  1. Get rid of Norton. Uninstall it completely. (McAfee too, for those that have that hot mess installed.) Again, remove it COMPLETELY, then run CCleaner to get rid of all leftover traces. Then install one (and ONLY one) of several fine and FREE antivirus programs available. My personal recommendation is Avast!, but AVG is okay too, if a little bloated. McAfee and Norton are crap. As “that guy who fixes computers”, I have seen those two programs cause more problems than they fix. Stay away from them.

    Reply
  2. For folk who like to experiment, sandboxie is excellent & free.
    It protects by throwing a barrier around your browser, then when you close the browser, everything is deleted,including any malware .It is possible to save outside the sandbox if required.
    Jp

    Reply
  3. As to Paul Masters comment on “get rid of Norton”..years ago I never liked it either, but got new computer year ago & Norton came with my internet provider so decided to try it. It’s been super so far but I use Malwarebytes (free version) also & run a full scan on that once in a while. But again, my Norton has not seemed to interfere with anything, not even ITunes updates, which can be really sensitive!

    Reply
  4. I have never liked Norton OR McAfee, and had to stop using Avast! (which I did like, and used for years) because the new version stopped my PC from booting up.
    Currently I have Microsoft Security Essentials and AVG on my desktop. They do their scheduled scans at different times, and do not seem to interfere with each other in real-time. If there IS a problem, 9 times out of 10 MSE will catch it. AVG just seems to repeatedly warn me about cookies.

    One browser add-on I will mention, is Web Of Trust. That gives me a handy indicator whether a link is likely to cause issues before i go there, and gives me the opportunity to ‘back out’ if i end up at a site it doesn’t like.

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.