Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

How do I record a streaming video?

How do I record a streaming video from an online website like YouTube?

In this excerpt from
Answercast #74
, I look at both the technical and legal ramifications of
downloading or recording streaming video from internet locations.

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

Recording streaming video

So this answer actually gets a little bit complicated in two ways. One is
technology and the other is legality, of all things.

Let’s start with the technology.

With respect to YouTube specifically, go out and Google the phrase “YouTube
downloader.” There are many pieces of software available out there that will
let you directly download a YouTube video. You don’t have do any recording at
all.

All you really need to do is download the video file from YouTube directly
and you’ll have what you’re looking for: an offline copy of the video.

Record your screen

Now, for other sources? Many of them are using “true streaming” where there
literally is no file to download. The only solution I’m aware of (and I’ve
actually done this a couple of times) is to use a screen recording
application.

I happen to use Camtasia, which is kind-of a higher end utility. There are a
couple of other alternatives out there (one of which may even be free, but the
name escapes me – perhaps someone will actually comment on this article and
give a suggestion on that.)

The bottom line is that you end up using a “screen recording” utility. You
have to make sure that it’s also recording the audio output that plays with the
video (Camtasia happens to.)

What that allows you to do is exactly as you describe: record what’s
happening on your screen. Then, you can save it to a video file in any number of
different formats; whatever you would like it to be.

So those are two ways of doing it. If you can, find a direct downloader
specifically for YouTube. Otherwise, you end up having to use screen recording
software; screen capturing software, much like (if not exactly) Camtasia.

Legalities of downloading

Now. Let’s talk about the legalities for a minute.

The problem is that what you’re doing is you’re making a copy of
this video. Many times (in fact, I would claim, in most cases) even
when there’s a YouTube download available, it’s not formally supported. It may
be illegal or at least against the Terms of Service of the site.

In other words, you’re not supposed to do what you’re trying to do in most
cases.

It’s unfortunate; it really is. In my case specifically, the reason I
actually want this (for things like YouTube) is that there are videos out there
that are available in High Definition. They look great! The problem is my
internet connection is slow enough that I can’t actually stream the
High Definition version. I would want to download it first and then play
it.

A YouTube downloader would let me get the High Definition version and then
play it while offline without relying on my internet connection.

Nonetheless, I do believe that’s against YouTube’s term of service.
Technically, it could be considered illegal.

So be very careful when you’re doing this. Pay attention to what the law
says or at least what the Terms of Service is. Most of these sites will tell
you. It’s something worth looking into it.

Obviously, I personally believe that there are perfectly ethical reasons to
do this; my scenario being one of them. But nonetheless, that doesn’t
necessarily mean that it’s legal.

Now, I do have to end this by saying I am not a lawyer and this isn’t legal
advice. But I do, at least, want to make you aware of the potential legal
ramifications of doing what it is you’re asking to do.

(Transcript lightly edited for readability.)

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

13 comments on “How do I record a streaming video?”

  1. I have had good success with http://www.savevid.com
    There is no need to download any software, it offers a range of output file formats and resolutions and supports a range of source sites, not just Youtube. And it is free.
    I don’t think that addresses the “pure streaming” issue but I prefer savevid to actually installing third party software.

    Reply
  2. There are two ways that I can record a streaming video on the Internet. And since I do not use this for anything except my personal viewing, the legal ramifications are minimal, as I still am obeying the essence of the law.

    WAY 1
    I discovered sometime back, that many/most streaming videos that I watch end up as a temporary Internet file. And since these videos are usually the largest such files in that folder, which Windows creates and uses, I locate them by sorting the files there by size. The name of the file may be a bit of gibberish, but it is always very easy to locate. If I want to watch the file, I move it to another folder, and rename it.

    It is best to go the Temporary Internet Folder ASAP, when you want to save the file, especially if you have your machine set to delete temp files when exiting the Internet.

    WAY 2
    I use a screen capture utility called FastStone capture. I have found it to be the best such utility out there. At $19.95, it is one of the best shareware products out there. It does everything, including video screen capture, and includes the audio. Once you have used it, it is extremely simple to use whenever it’s needed again.

    It’s also great when creating a video lesson/presentation. It will capture the screen display, and record the audio from the computer’s mike input.

    The program must be used to appreciate its capabilities, options, and features.

    Reply
  3. Trying to record video is the most frustrating thing I have tried to do. This because the Freebies never seem to work as well as I would like. Trying to find right codec’s etc is a little over my head. Like earlier comments I also found that Cam Studio was the best I have tried so far. Still, although I have downloaded their Lossless codec I have a feeling that this is not 100% suitable for video as such and is only suitable for static screens.
    Perhaps Leo you could shed some light on this matter.

    Reply
  4. Watch the videos!

    I would download Jawor’s Xvid or Lagarith Lossless if you are doing any motion recording. CamStudio Lossless is only for tutorials with static screens.

    Found the above in Cam Studio support forum !!

    Reply
  5. I’ve been using PlayLater (http://www.playlater.tv/) to record and then playback while on the treadmill. It doesn’t record HD, however, so if that’s a criterion then it may not work for you. Recordings fail occasionally (most often from CBS), so I’ve found that I cannot just queue them up and leave.

    Reply
  6. I use a cheap piece of hardware bought off eBay. It connects between the VGA port on the PC and the VGA input of the monitor. Powered from a USB port, it produces composite video (PAL, NTSC) that can then feed into my conventional TV-type DVD recorder. Job done!

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.