Regarding downloads: if, for example, I search and click on very funny Texas
Hold’em and just sit and play, does that constitute a download? Or is it a
download only if I save it somewhere in my system? This has always confused me.
You’ve probably already answered it somewhere. If so, just point me to it.
In this excerpt from
Answercast #11, I discuss how your ISP considers downloads, why that may
differ from what you think of as a download, and the difference between
streaming and downloading a video.
Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!
What is a download?
There are a couple of places where I talk about downloads, but to be honest,
it’s a confusing subject. I get that.
The problem is that it depends on specifically what you mean. What is
the reason that you’re trying to characterize it as a download or not? Realize
that (regardless of what you do with it) any data that comes from your ISP to your
computer is downloading data.
What you do with it then…
- You could be playing a game
- You could be downloading and saving a game
… But the bottom line is that all of that data was downloaded through your
What your ISP sees as a download
If you’re looking at it from an ISP’s perspective, they actually don’t care;
they don’t distinguish. They are just looking at the number of bytes that are
going down the pike between their system and yours.
It’s interesting because something like a game (a card game in the
example that you’re giving) is typically a small program. It could be written
your browser, that program is actually being downloaded from the server on
which it resides to your computer, so that you can play it.
Technically, there’s a download going on in this very example. It’s just very
well hidden from you.
When you visit a website like Ask Leo!, the contents of that page are
downloaded to your PC and that’s where you actually view it from.
If the page you’re viewing has pictures, those pictures are downloaded to
your PC, and you’re actually viewing them off of your own hard disk.
Basically, anything that happens on the internet, anything that involves
getting data from the internet to your PC is a download in one form or
Streaming and downloading
I will point you at an article that I wrote a while back regarding video and
that is “What’s
the difference between streaming and downloading a video?“
The reason I point you to that one is that it’s a wonderful example of how you
can download a video and have it on your PC, or you can watch the video
streaming. As we see in both cases, you’re downloading the entire contents
of the video to your PC. It’s a matter of what you do with it then. You either
watch it immediately in the streaming case or you save it as a file.
Again, from a downloading perspective, it’s no different. You’re still
downloading. You’re still transferring that same information across the wire
from the server which is out on the internet to your PC.