Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Do you really need anti-virus software?

Common wisdom is that you do, but the answer might surprise you.

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!


Transcript

This is Leo Notenboom for askleo.info.

Every so often I get asked by someone if they really need anti-virus
software.

Common wisdom is that you do, and true to that label it’s a wise thing to
do. In fact, if you have any doubt what the answer to the question is, then the
answer for you is clearly, positively yes. Yes you do need to run anti-virus
software, and of course keep it up to date.

But you can tell from the way I put that, I left us an out.

Here’s the deal – anti-virus software monitors and scans for and
(hopefully) eradicates any viruses that appear on your machine.

Well, what if they never appear? Or if they do appear, what if they never
get executed?

Well, then it follows that your anti-virus software is kinda redundant.
Perhaps even pointless.

So there you go: if you can be 100% certain that you’re able to prevent
viruses from even reaching your machine or you’re 100% certain that a virus
would never get executed, then you’re done. You don’t need anti-virus
software.

“I run anti-virus software and I have for years.”

Remember: you need to be 100% certain.

Now, it may sound like I’m being a little sarcastic or facetious, and I
suppose I am a little. But on the other hand, I do know people who match that
criteria. A good friend of mine runs without anti-virus software. He’s not a
geek, but he is very internet savvy. He can get away with it because he knows what
he’s doing.

Personally, I run anti-virus software and I have for years. But to be
totally honest, I probably haven’t had to. I’ve never been infected and the
anti-virus software has never detected an actual threat. Like my friend, I
too kind of know what I’m doing and how to avoid viruses in the first
place.

But I have come close a time or two. I almost fell for a phishing scam some
months ago. Had I done so, it could have resulted in a real infection.

So I’ll keep running anti-virus software. In my opinion it’s cheap
insurance even for those who know what they’re doing, or especially those who
just think they do.

As for everyone else? It’s a requirement. Run anti-virus software and make
sure to keep it’s database of threats up to date.

Oh, and get behind a firewall. Everyone needs that – know-it-alls and
newbies alike. That’s actually a key part of keeping the viruses at bay in the
first place.

I’d love to hear what you think. Visit askleo.info and enter 11905 in the go
to article number box to access the show notes, the transcript and to leave me
a comment. While you’re there, browse over 1,200 technical questions and
answers on the site.

Till next time, I’m Leo Notenboom, for askleo.info.

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

13 comments on “Do you really need anti-virus software?”

  1. This might have only a slight relation to the title but read this bit and then delete if u must 🙁 ——–>I have sent you a e-mail at [removed] if you could reply to that, that would be great,in relation to this does port forwarding open up a route past ur firewall and anti-virus and how do you do it.I have done everything I have a ip address ive set up the ports UDP and TCP or whatever they are cant remember for a netopia 2247 to use on utorrent but it wont work im runnig windows xp pro sp 2.

    Reply
  2. I agree 100% Leo. I am one of those that knows and my AV has not had to work for over 2 years. I keep it around as it is not intrusive and requires minimal attention (unlike some AV’s starting with an “N”.)

    A good Firewall is essential. A bad one is better than standing in the middle of the road, but get a good one (research, research, research).

    Thanks for all the pearls Leo. Makes us know-it’s feel we are not as stupid as the commoners think.

    Reply
  3. Hi,
    Unless you’re really good with computer security, you need AntiVirus, AntiSpyware, and a reliable Firewall. The casual user will not be able to stop their system from becoming vulnerable.

    Reply
  4. I have an old cheap underpowered laptop in the kitchen on a wireless connection. I look at the weather and read the news on from Washington Post, yahoo, MSNBC and the like in the early morning. I put AV on it and it was so slow and it took 5-10 minutes to boot up. My coffee was made before it booted up. I took off the AV and it runs fine. It has been a year now and I haven’t had any problems, but I don’t visit any odd web sites.

    Reply
  5. I was advised by one of my brother-in-laws that works on computers daily. He told me that “N” and “M” do not check there own execution files when searching for virus’s. He pointed me towards AVAST anti-virus. Have never had a problem with it and it has caught virus trying to sneak in a couple of times now. I won’t run without AV or spybot. Even though I have been around awhile, there is always the chance that I will stumble into something that would be bad. Thanks for all the advice you give out, I find it very informative.

    Reply
  6. Dear Leo, just like you, I have never lost a single bit because of viruses for 20 years, but I do always have an anti-virus software running.

    However, I think I am not that agreeable that we can be safe without anti-virus software. This may be true in the olden days where nothing get executed without you explicitly do so. Nowadays worms can get into our system (especially for Ms. Windows) and get executed. Even we ensure our systems are properly patched and firewall running, the risk is still there.

    Reply
  7. i have always used 1 anti-virus and 1 firewall ( apart from windows)afterall when you leave home you lock your doors dont you.

    Reply
  8. Yeah Leo, I totally agree with you on this one. In my opinion, the anti-virus program is not at all such a necessity in case of knowledgeable computer users. In fact, I would even recommend against it because of the stress (i.e. file-system level monitoring of files opening/closing/etc.) that it puts on a user’s system. But yeah, a good firewall (like for instance XP SP2’s, don’t ask me why!!) is a completely different matter …

    And as I wrote in my post in the “Anti-virus necessary?”: http://episteme.arstechnica.com/eve/…/m/116001624831 thread on forumu on Ars Technica website:

    “Well, IMO the problem in our cases (of computer savvy users) can be that we disable the “real-time” protection (I most certainly recommend this, at least for example during software installations, applying various updates etc.), and so we can be infected then when protection is off.

    For instance, I use Avast! anti-virus program, and I enable its “on-access” protection only when I am connected to the Internet, and even then only the “Web Shield” component. As I mentioned many times already, I mostly visit the same set of sites every day, then I practice the “common sense” thing in surfing the web etc. etc., so I haven’t got any problem (with a few exceptions, which were all my experimenting’s/stupidity’s fault) with viruses or any other form of malware for years!!”

    P.S., I also touched this issue/subject in great details in this entry: http://tadej.sopca.com/2007/10/05/o-uporabineuporabi-anti-virusnih-programov/ on my slovenian blog; although it’s in slovenian language you might understand some parts of it.

    ________

    best regards,
    Ivan Tadej, Slovenia
    http://tadej-ivan.50webs.com/

    Reply
  9. I have 3 Windows 7 laptops and none of them have any anti-virus software on them. I don’t believe in anti-virus software because I think they could cause more problems than solve them. It could give a false reading and tell me I have a virus, when I don’t and block access to my other software. On Windows 7 we have Windows Defender and Malicious Software Removal Tool-MRT. And these two tools both scan and remove viruses and malware. But at the same time,they don’t take over your computer like an anti-virus program does. That is YOU control how you want these programs to run and when they scan. Andrea Borman.

    Reply
  10. I’d like to see a 2011 Win7 update to this question…have your thoughts changed, stayed the same, any other thoughts?

    McAfee pop-ups from the bundled software from Dell is almost as annoying than an actual virus. “Do you want to buy?” “Your protection is over in a month. Now do you want to buy?” “Now?” “Now?” “Special, 1-time offer–want to buy?” “Same special 1-time offer again–want to buy now?”

    And on and on. Any thoughts?

    Yes, you definitely still need anti-virus software. Check out What Security Software do you recommend?

    Leo
    14-Jun-2011

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.