Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

Can I take the old hard drive out of a failed laptop, put it in an enclosure and connect it to my new laptop?

I’m buying a new laptop. Can I take the hard drive out of my old laptop, put
in an enclosure with a USB connection, and plug into my new laptop? I want to
play the games which cannot be transferred. Will the operating system on the
USB hard drive interfere with the operating system on the new laptop? Any help
will be appreciated.

In this excerpt from
Answercast #77
, I look at using a hard drive from an old laptop as an
external hard drive. It probably won’t play games.

]]>

Taking an old hard drive to a new computer

So, the answer to the two questions that you’ve asked is yes and yes – but the answer to the very important question that you didn’t ask is no.

Let me walk through that.

Can you put that old hard drive in an enclosure and connect it up to your laptop? Absolutely! In fact, I recommend it as a very convenient way to be able to move data – and to actually have a useful hard drive out of what would otherwise be a dead laptop. So yes, absolutely, you can do that.

Using the old software

Will you be able to play the games that can’t be transferred? No. The problem is that anything that required a set up (which almost all games do) needs to have that set up run when the game is to be played on a different computer.

Basically, you need to reinstall the game.

You can’t just plug in the hard drive that contains the images and expect it to work. It’s not going to.

The problem is that the game is going to need to have things installed in Windows. It’s going to have settings that it expects in the registry; it’s going to need a number of things that all happen when that program is “set up” for the first time from the setup disc or from the installation media or from the installation download.

None of that will be there if you just plugged the disk in. The only way to get those games over to this other computer is to reinstall them from scratch.

Competing operating systems

And then finally, “Will the operating system on the USB hard drive interfere with the operating system on the new laptop?” No, not necessarily.

The only thing that I can think that might cause a problem is if your computer is set up to boot from USB. In other words, if it checks for a USB device to boot from before it checks the hard drive, it’s possible that it might try and boot from the external hard drive.

There are two solutions to that.

  • One is don’t plug in the USB external hard drive until after you’ve booted.

  • Or you go into your BIOS and change the “priority order” of the boot devices. Make sure that the BIOS, when it’s boot time, will look for something on the hard drive (or maybe the CD ROM) before it looks for something on USB.

If you ever need to boot from USB, of course, you’ll need to change the order back. But to avoid booting from USB, you just want to make sure that the hard drive is in order before the USB device.

(Transcript lightly edited for readability.)

Do this

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Less frustration and more confidence, solutions, answers, and tips in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

7 comments on “Can I take the old hard drive out of a failed laptop, put it in an enclosure and connect it to my new laptop?”

  1. Of course if he did boot to his USB drive, then he could play those games. But it might be a bit slower than from the C: drive. 🙂

    It’s unlikely booting from that old hard drive would work as the Windows install has drivers for the old laptop, and it may not be able to reconfigure itself on the fly to the configuration of the new laptop.

    Leo
    11-Dec-2012
    Reply
  2. Another possibility should be to use partitioning software like Easeus Partition Manager to make the (now external USB) drive NOT be “active” any more.

    Reply
  3. It depends on how old the game software is. Try running it and see what errors you get. It could be a stand alone game that doesn’t update the registry, and all you need to do is install something like DosBox to get it to run, or some type of software to allow very old games to run on your system.

    Reply
  4. If it boots from the USB drive, will it regard that as Drive C: ? And will it use the Registry on the USB drive – which will have all its references aiming at Drive C:.

    Or am I wrong (again) ?

    Reply
  5. @Robin

    The ‘old’ hard drive may TRY to boot in the USB position, but it won’t complete.

    Consider: Old machine..a chipset, a processor, drivers for all sorts of things #audio, NIC…# to make it work. New machine…it’s pretty much a given that IT will be 100% different.

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.