Technology in terms you understand. Sign up for the Confident Computing newsletter for weekly solutions to make your life easier. Click here and get The Ask Leo! Guide to Staying Safe on the Internet — FREE Edition as my thank you for subscribing!

A program is telling me to uninstall its competitor; should I?

I get this message every time I start Spybot which follows:
“Spybot-Search&Destroy has detected that you have the following
product installed. This may cause incompatibilities; for more
information click Yes to visit our website”, etc. And then lists:
LavaSoft AdAware which I do have installed on my computer. Should I
remove one the these two programs or keep them both and live with the
message?

I’ve never seen this message, but its presence doesn’t surprise
me.

Spybot and AdAware are two programs that do the same thing: they’re
anti-spyware scanners.

And while it might be easy to think that this is simply one program
calling out its competitor, it’s much more likely that there’s an
honest technical reason for the message.

Become a Patron of Ask Leo! and go ad-free!

In general it’s a bad idea to run two real-time anti-virus or
anti-spyware products at the same time. To clarify that a little:

  • You should run both an anti-virus program and an
    anti-spyware program.

  • Both of those may have “real time” scanning components, and that’s
    ok.

  • You should not have two anti-virus programs running real-time
    components simultaneously; they are likely to conflict.

  • You should not have two anti-spyware programs running real-time
    components simultaneously; they are likely to conflict.

  • You certainly can run as many different non-real time scans as you
    like, as long as they’re not run at the same time.

“In general it’s a bad idea to run two real-time
anti-virus or anti-spyware products at the same time.”

So what do I mean by “real time”?

Real time scanning is software that runs in the background and scans
for malware while you go about your daily tasks. It might examine your
downloads as you’re downloading them, or scan your email as it comes
in. It happens as you do it, in real time.

The alternative is a stand-alone or “static” scan. You initiate a
scan, it scans your system, reports anything it finds, and it exits.
Nothing is installed, nothing remains, it simply looks for problems and
then goes away.

The problem is that real time scanners need to “hook into” the
system to perform their scans. And if more than one scanner attempts to
hook in for real time scans, they can conflict with each other.

My guess is that Spybot is noticing that AdAware is hooked in, and
warning you of the potential conflict.

There are a few approaches you can take.

You can, of course, simply choose one or the other. In all honesty,
this is my suggestion. Both are good products, and there’s rarely a
case where you really need both.

The alternative is to turn off any real time components in one of
the two. Exactly how that’s done depends on the product, but look for
terms like “resident”, “real time” and the like. If I’m not mistaken, I
think Spybot has the oddly named “tea timer” as a real time component
as well.

That way, only one product will protect you while you use your
computer, and you then can use the other periodically “on demand” to
perform static scans of your system.

But good for you for using anti-spyware software. You’re ahead of
many people in this regard.

Subscribe to Confident Computing! Tech problem solving & safety tips & a weekly confidence boost in your inbox every week.

I'll see you there!

10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow

Slow Computer?

Speed up with my special report: 10 Reasons Your Computer is Slow, now updated for Windows 10.

NOW: name your own price! You decide how much to pay -- and yes, that means you can get this report completely free if you so choose. Get your copy now!

12 comments on “A program is telling me to uninstall its competitor; should I?”

  1. I use both Ad-Aware and Spybot and have not seen this message before. Although, I have seen it prior to downloading other anti-virus apps. I agree with Leo’s assessment that the key here is ‘real-time’. I use free version of both of these products and use them ‘on demand’. By doing so, it has yet to cause a conflict.

    Reply
  2. I have have two real time spyware running with no problem or slow down, spyware terminator and windows defender and 1 on demand scanner

    Reply
  3. I have had this same ‘pop-up’ screen; many times. I use different op systems and now a new hard drive and I know my utility programs. So while downloading updates I download my utility programs. Just make sure the asked program is not running and go ahead. I’ve been using both of the above mentioned programs for years and have no programs with them..separately. I consider it a non-issue and move on!!!!!

    Reply
  4. I too have used both utilities (free versions) and have seen the message that SBSD provides. Can’t recall, but there may have been a “don’t show this message again” choice on the popup. I have had no problems with using both programs. Both are passive protection.

    Reply
  5. While it is not advisable to run 2 real-time anti-virus programs at the same time (they HAVE components that one can almost identify as a “virus”, to “recognise” a virus), it is normally NOT a problem to run 2 or more anti-spyware real-time programs! NOTE: Spybot uses the “Tea-timer”, which also acts as a “firewall” against spyware. It is imperative, to disable this accessory from Spybot. And, along the lines of firewalls, if one uses a decent firewall, then you should also disable the WINDOWS Firewall! I personally use Jetico for my firewall, Avast! Anti-virus Professional, PC Tools Spyware Doctor AND SUPERAntiSpyware, in real-time configuration!
    Also, you should check which version of Spybot you are using, as there was also a version out that had a number of bugs, and unless one is above the average user, NOT the “beta” version!
    Using 2 similar programs, although NOT in identical modes, is a good idea! One always “checks” the other one!

    Reply
  6. Question similar what this person went through. I installed Spybot and did my best to delete/uninstall it. I think it messed up MY registry and iexplorer program (tools options locked, often can’t print and can’t hear some of flashplayer sound when I run moviesl) Its driving me crazy…I’ve tried all the usual remedies I’ve read about, but no good! Can you help?

    Linda

    Reply
  7. I use both Ad Aware and Spybot, both are the free versions and each time I run Spybot I get the message about the program conflict and I ignore the message. as these are passive programs and only check for errors when you issue a scan command. I have found that in the past Spybot will find items Ad aware dose not find and Ad Aware finds items Spybot has missed.

    Reply
  8. I used to run both AdAaware and Spybot, both occasionally finding different items. However I had to get my local shop to reinstall Windows XP for me when I crashed in the summer and his recommendation was to use (only) Windows Defender for spyware. He put on Avast 4.8 but the reviews seem marginally to favou AVG 8.0

    Reply
  9. To expand on the comment that AC2 made:
    The reason that Spybot recommends not using another antispyware is that spybot replaces some adware files with similar files without a payload aka “dummies”. Let’s say that a certain adware package is required to use another product on your computer that you still want to use. Spybot will replace the file that serves the ads and violates your privacy and replace it with another file that makes the product still think you are viewing ads, and so it still works. Essentially, uninstalling certain ad software will make the programs that rely on it not work, so Spybot tricks those programs. Hope that wasn’t too confusing.

    Bearing all that in mind, another antispyware product might think the dummies are the original malware and try to remove them, rendering the programs relying on it inoperable. So, if you do run another program (I run several antispyware and antivirus one after the other) just remember which files Spybot replaced (look atthe logs).

    Reply
  10. I don’t like Spybot or Adaware anymore, they both have become very bloated apps and it seems all they catch are cookies. While I do use 2 antivirus apps (avira – realtime, kaspersky – non realtime), I feel my best protection is Acronis TrueImage. I have partitioned my c: drive to only 10 gigs (only 5 is used) used only for my os (xp sp3) and a d: drive for everything else. It’s easy to move your mydocs to d: and a simple registry hack to move your “Program Files”
    to d:(google “moving “program files” to d:). So if anything at all happens to my os it’s just a few minutes to reinstall my imaged c:. My surfing habits take me to many questionable sites and yet I sleep very well at night.

    I agree: having good backups is one of the best sleep-aids I know of. 🙂

    – Leo
    19-Oct-2008
    Reply
  11. While it’s true that most warnings involve anti-malware programs which can actually interfere with each other, I have seen a rare occasion when other programs will detect the installation of a competitor and demand, no less, not simply warn, that the competitor must be removed. Since I know for a fact that the competitor is not running at the time, and will not interfere, I flatly refuse to comply. Or I simply won’t use the one being installed. Basically…

    Whichever one makes me choose,
    Is the one that will lose.

    Reply

Leave a reply:

Before commenting please:

  • Read the article.
  • Comment on the article.
  • No personal information.
  • No spam.

Comments violating those rules will be removed. Comments that don't add value will be removed, including off-topic or content-free comments, or comments that look even a little bit like spam. All comments containing links and certain keywords will be moderated before publication.

I want comments to be valuable for everyone, including those who come later and take the time to read.